Raptors vs. Cavaliers: Is Cleveland in danger of an early exit? Series keys, calendar and prediction

The Cleveland Cavaliers, the fourth seed in the Eastern Conference, face the fifth seed Toronto Raptors in the first round of the tournament. 2026 NBA Playoffs. The teams haven’t played each other in the postseason since 2018, when LeBron James still owned Toronto.

What we know about the Cavaliers

They’re probably better today than they were at the start of this season, all things considered, but neither version of these Cavaliers is better than they were at various points in last season’s 64-win season, which ended in the second round of the playoffs.

Announcement

Despite averaging 54 wins over the past four seasons, Cleveland has won two series in three previous trips to the playoffs in the Donovan Mitchell era, and that’s not good enough given how good they’ve been and how much talent they have around them.

Some of them were redundant in the All-Star quartet of Mitchell and Darius Garland, Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen. Mobley’s development as a rising star stagnated, and Garland’s injury problems persisted. The Cavs were taking a step in the wrong direction.

They needed a jolt and they got a big one in early February. First, Cleveland executive Koby Altman traded a disappointing De’Andre Hunter for both Keon Ellis and Dennis Schröder from the Sacramento Kings, a brilliant move that bolsters depth. A few days later, Altman turned Garland into James Harden, a more curious decision.

Announcement

So, here we are, with a 36-year-old Harden in place of a 26-year-old Garland in lineups that boast Mitchell, Mobley and Allen — lineups that are +52 in 92 minutes combined. Meanwhile, the Cavs are deeper than ever on the wing, where Max Strus, Dean Wade, Jaylon Tyson and Sam Merrill can play, along with Ellis and Schröder.

This is a real spin. Not that we know what to expect. Cleveland has fielded 41 different lineups this year; none of them started more than six games together. We just think we know what to expect from these Cavaliers, since we’ve seen both them and Harden separately and have repeatedly reached the limit of the second-round playoffs.

Together, perhaps, they create magic. That’s the beauty of the postseason. Every playoff campaign is a new chance to rewrite your legacy. If Harden and the Cavs can’t, we have to imagine bigger changes are on the horizon in Cleveland.

What we know about the Raptors

The Raptors would like nothing more than to reach the playoff ceiling in the second round. They haven’t made the playoffs since 2022, they haven’t won a series since 2020. Gone are all the remnants of the 2019 title team, including Kawhi Leonard, Pascal Siakam, OG Anunoby, Fred VanVleet and Norman Powell — a good roster if you can still get it.

Announcement

In their place is another expensive rotation, boasting Scottie Barnes, Brandon Ingram, Immanuel Quickley, RJ Barrett and Jakob Poeltl, a starting lineup owed a total of $156.5 million this year. They won 30 games together all last season.

Granted, that group didn’t feature a healthy Ingram in 2024-25. Position him next to Barnes and you’ll have a lot of length on the perimeter. Ingram made the All-Star team as a replacement. Barnes, also an All-Star, is expected to make both the All-NBA and All-Defensive ballots.

The team is full of good players, including Quickley, Barrett and Poeltl. His bench of Jamal Shead, Collin Murray-Boyles, Sandro Mamukelashvili and Ja’Kobe Walter is one of the most underrated groups in the league. They have even more talent behind them. It was never about their respective abilities; it was about the collective.

Announcement

And Raptors coach Darko Rajaković has found a way this season to get everyone rowing in the same direction. It could also be, given that they are all under contract for next season too. Everyone got paid. It’s time to win. So, to some extent, they posted a top-five defense, which was good enough to drag a mediocre offense to 48 wins.

They’re missing a superstar, the guy who can get them buckets in tough moments, and who could backfire on them in the playoffs. Their defense has kept them in games all season, but the postseason is a different animal. Sure, Barnes, Ingram, Barrett and Quickley can all create, but can they match up late with Mitchell, or even Harden?

Head to head

The Raptors won the regular season series against the Cavaliers, 3-0.

Announcement

All three meetings took place before the end of November, when Garland was still with the Cavaliers, only he wasn’t available for any of them, which is partly why they traded him for Harden. Allen also missed a couple of games. Mitchell only played in two of them. It is difficult to gather relevant information from Cleveland.

As for the Raptors, their starting lineup – Quickley, Barrett, Ingram, Barnes and Poeltl – was +8 in 12 minutes of two games (against a completely different Cavaliers rotation).

You know who was great against Cleveland this year? Mamukelashvili (+28 in 57 minutes) and Shead (+39 in 70 minutes). The two on the bench outperformed their opponents, and that’s what they do. Of course, the Cavs now have reserves that they didn’t have at the time.

Match worth watching

Scottie Barnes vs. Evan Mobley

Barnes, one of the NBA’s most versatile defenders, has spent more time on few other players this season than Mobley. He defended Mobley for parts of 113 possessions, and the Cavaliers scored just 98 points. This is a Cleveland team that scored 118.3 points per 100 possessions, as the sixth-most efficient offense in the league.

Announcement

The same can be said of Mobley, another of the NBA’s most versatile defenders. He spent much of his time against the Raptors on Barnes, helping hold Toronto to just 85.9 points per 100 possessions in those minutes. It’s an old-fashioned head-to-head defensive battle between two of the best players capable of doing so.

How much can Barnes help Mobley? Can Mobley, who has shot just 30.5% on wide open 3s this year, keep Barnes, with Poeltl, from clogging up the paint, where Mitchell and Harden will want to operate, along with Allen, away from Toronto’s best defender?

Likewise, how much will Mobley make Barnes work on the offensive end? Barnes shot just 24% on 3-point pull-up attempts for the season. The last thing the Raptors want is for Mobley to roam free, with Allen, while Quickley, Barrett and Ingram try to create.

Announcement

None of their offensive plays are all that reliable. If Barnes and Mobley end up neutralizing each other, you have to appreciate Cleveland’s chances with the ball in the hands of both Mitchell and Harden. The Cavs’ two-guard lineups, which included a combination of Mitchell, Garland and Ty Jerome last season, torched the Raptors. Now they can arm such a triumvirate of Mitchell, Harden and Schröder.

Both teams have many offensive weapons. Each has a defensive monster to counter those arsenals, and the series could come down to which of them can have a broader impact, even beyond man-to-man mutual defense.

Key question

Which version of Harden will take the floor for the Cavaliers?

We should all be familiar with Harden’s weaknesses in the playoffs. A result of 3 for 11 on the biggest stage is not unusual for him. Which is pretty shocking for one of the greatest regular season offensive engines in the history of the sport. His solo act has never quite translated to the postseason, when defenses can really hone in on how to stop a one-man show.

Announcement

Worst of all was when Harden, as a perennial MVP candidate, avoided the moment entirely, letting his teammates solve an offense that was entirely built for him.

But in Cleveland, Harden doesn’t need to be the superstar he was. In fact, the Cavs would rather it wasn’t. The high usage falls on Mitchell, one of the greatest individual performers in playoff history. Only a handful of players, including Michael Jordan and LeBron James, average more than Mitchell’s 28.3 playoff points per game.

Harden must work primarily on the weak side of the ball, making open chances (he’s shot 40% on catch-and-shoot 3-point opportunities this season) and attacking in close quarters. When Mitchell is not on the court, Harden can work his two-man game with Allen, a devastating combination, so an elite creator can always remain on the court.

Announcement

What happens if Harden craters again? It’s already a defensive weakness, and if it becomes one offensively, it’s a hole in an otherwise contender. (Again.) Sure, the Cavs can survive against Toronto without an additive version of Harden, but it would haunt them in the later rounds, and they don’t want to see any evidence of that now.

Prediction: Cavaliers in six

I expect close matches. As a group, Toronto’s offense has managed just 106.9 points per 100 possessions, a bottom-10 figure. Meanwhile, since Harden first took the floor for Cleveland, the Cavaliers are scoring 131 points per 100 possessions. Dare we say trust in Mitchell and Harden (or at least more than Barnes and Ingram)?

Series betting odds

(Via BetMGM)

Announcement

Cleveland Cavaliers (-700)

Toronto Raptors (+500)

Program of the series

Game 1: Saturday, April 18 in Cleveland (1 p.m., Prime)

Game 2: Monday, April 20 in Cleveland (7 p.m., Peacock)

Game 3: Thursday, April 23 in Toronto (8 p.m., Prime)

Game 4: Sunday, April 26 in Toronto (1 p.m., ESPN)

*Game 5: Wednesday 29 April in Cleveland (to be defined)

*Game 6: Friday May 1st in Toronto (to be defined)

*Game 7: Sunday 3 May in Cleveland (to be defined)

*if necessary